Al and Kelly's Newton Lake Inn Menu

Welcome to Al and Kelly's Newton Lake Inn, a charming eatery nestled in Athelstane, Wisconsin. Known for its inviting atmosphere and friendly service, this local gem offers a delightful dining experience that resonates with both residents and visitors alike.

The menu features a variety of dishes that emphasize quality and flavor. Diners rave about the pizzas, celebrated for their perfect crust and generous toppings. Daily food specials provide excellent value, making it a great choice for a casual lunch or a hearty dinner. Customers like Dan VanRoo and Gloria Puyleart have praised the overall experience, highlighting not just the food but the warm, community-oriented vibe that Al and Kelly’s fosters.

  • Cozy corner bar setting
  • Friendly, attentive staff
  • Reasonably priced dishes

Whatever your craving, you’re guaranteed a memorable visit at Al and Kelly’s, where good food meets good company.

Finger Foods

French Fries

US$3.00

Beer Battered Fries

US$3.25

Fries Chips

US$3.00

Cheesy Tator Rounds

US$3.50

Fried Cheese Curds

US$3.50

Mozzarella Sticks

US$4.00

Onion Rings

US$3.50

Mushrooms

US$3.50

Portabella Mushrooms

US$3.50

Deep Fried Pickles

US$3.50

Deep Fired Green Beans

US$3.50

Combo Basket

US$6.50

Poppers

US$4.25

Nacho Cheese & Chips

US$3.50

Garlic Toast (3 pc.)

US$3.00

Wing Zings

US$5.50

Hamburger (1/2 lb.)

US$4.50

Hamburger (1/4 lb.)

US$3.00

Cheeseburger (1/2 lb.)

US$4.75

Combo Burger

US$5.75

Pepper Jack Burger (1/2 lb.)

US$5.00

Grilled Chicken

US$5.75

Garlic Italian Grilled Chicken

US$5.75

Jumbo Grilled Hot Dog

Brat Patty

US$4.50

Pizza Burger

US$4.50

Italian Hot Beef

US$5.00

BBQ Pork

US$4.25

Pork Chop

US$5.00

Fish Sandwich (Beer battered cod)

US$6.25

Hot Ham & Cheese

US$4.50

Grilled Cheese

US$2.25

Sandwiches

Specials

Chicken or Taco Wraps

US$5.50

Soup or Chili

US$3.25

Soup or Chili

Baskets

Chicken Nuggets

US$6.25

Chicken Strips

US$6.25

Chicken Wings

US$6.75

Perch or Walleye Fry

US$11.00

Fish Fry (Cod)

US$9.50

Shrimp

US$10.50

Baked Cod & Red Potato

US$10.00

Platter Basket

US$11.00

B.L.T. Pizza

Four Meat Pizza

Newton Lake Inn's Homemade Pizza